Showing posts with label Iranian Presidential Debates. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Iranian Presidential Debates. Show all posts

Monday, June 10, 2013

News Post June 10, 2013

The Last Iranian Presidential Debate

The last debate before Iran's presidential election was held this past Friday, and the event was certainly more spirited than the previous two sessions.

The part I'd like to focus on is the sharp exchange that occurred between Rouhani (a reformist and cleric) and Ghalibaf (current mayor of Tehran and a conservative). It can be seen in this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IoJJnAi_hzw

After Rouhani made a comment about providing peace for Iranians, Ghalibaf criticized him for his handling of student protests in 2003 when Rouhani was Secretary of the National Security Council. This kicked off an exchange where the two candidates traded remarks about their own versions of how the situation was handled (Ghalibaf was the head of police at the time).

In the clip, Ghalibaf says Rouhani denied granting the students in question permission to protest in 2003. Rouhani counters by saying he was concerned that if the he granted them permission and they left campus, the police under Ghalibaf would arrest all of them. Rouhani goes on to say that he wasn't concerned about the students because he felt they would dissipate in a few days time.

The exchange continued in this manner, with the candidates giving conflicting accounts of events, neither of which can really be verified. Hopefully the high energy of this debate will help capture Iranian interest, which had been low, in the elections which are now just 4 days away.    

 

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

News Post June 3, 2013

The first Iranian Presidential debate occurred three days ago and featured all eight candidates. The debate was not without controversy, though, as several of the participants called the format into question. The following articles discuss the debate and the aforementioned controversy.

The first article comes from the BBC's Persian language site, www.bbc.co.uk/persian.


Article Points:
  • The author starts by pointing out that Tehran is often called the world's (دنیا) cosmetic surgery capital (پایتخت جراحی زیبایی). He then uses cosmetic surgery as a metaphor for the issues the candidates are discussing. The author feels they're superficial and don't address the real challenges facing Iran.
 
The second article comes from ghanoondaily.ir.

 
 
The title translates: IQ Test (تست هوش) in First (نخستین) Debate (مناضره) 

The subtitle in red translates loosely as: The candidates (نامزدها) prescription (نسخه) for healing(شفابخشي) the country's (کسور) economy (اقتصاد) was not given (تجويز نكردن)


The full article in Ghanoon is much longer, but it essentially describes part of the debate's format which was structured as multiple choice questions. Candidates were prompted with a question by the debate moderator, and asked to respond with one of three answers (hence the tongue and cheek title 'IQ Test.' Several of the candidates called the format childish and refused to participate. 

Some journalists have speculated that the debate was structured in such a way to avoid any explosive confrontations, like the one that broke out between President Ahmadinejad and challenger Mousavi in 2009.   

As a little background, here is a link to the debate between Ahmadinejad and Mousavi. Ahmadinejad, who was facing criticism following the discovery that one of his political appointees had lied about his possession of a doctoral degree, presented a file on Mousavi's wife. Ahmadinejad then claimed Mousavi's wife had falsely obtained her advanced degrees and then illegally secured a position as president of an Iranian university. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Luvx4gwgdSg

Also, here is a link to a collection of scenes from the last debate when things were breaking down and some candidates refused to answer questions:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SNOVvIbbuBU